MBBS vs CA — Which is Tough in India? Salary, Scope, Difficulty & Reality (2025)
MBBS vs CA — Which is Tough in India? Salary, Scope, Duration & Reality (2025)
If you’ve ever wondered MBBS vs CA — which is tough in India, which career gives a higher salary, or even debated CA vs Doctor — which is better on Quora or Reddit, this detailed guide clears every doubt. Let’s compare both India’s most respected and toughest professional paths — Medicine (MBBS) and Chartered Accountancy (CA).
Related Reads
- Difference Between PHP and HTML — PHP vs HTML vs JavaScript Explained
- Difference Between FTP and HTTP with Example, PDF, Class 12 Notes
- Software Engineer vs Cyber Security — Salary, Future, and Career Growth
- Software Engineer vs Web Developer — Salary, Skills, Reddit Insights, and Career Scope
MBBS vs CA — Quick Overview
Both MBBS and CA demand intense dedication, long study hours, and high intellectual ability. However, the nature of their toughness differs — MBBS challenges your memory and patience over years of study, while CA tests your analytical and conceptual clarity in multiple high-stakes exams.
| Parameter | MBBS (Doctor) | CA (Chartered Accountant) |
|---|---|---|
| Full Form | Bachelor of Medicine and Bachelor of Surgery | Chartered Accountancy |
| Course Duration | 5.5 years (including internship) | 4.5–5 years (including articleship) |
| Entrance Exam | NEET-UG | CA Foundation (after 12th) |
| Difficulty Level | High — vast syllabus, long duration | Extremely High — low pass rate (8–12%) |
| Pass Percentage | About 55–60% | Average 10–12% |
| Average Salary (India) | ₹6–10 LPA (Fresh MBBS) | ₹8–15 LPA (Fresh CA) |
| Top Recruiters | Hospitals, Clinics, Govt Sector | Big 4, Corporates, Banks, Firms |
| Global Demand | High (especially with specialization) | High (India & abroad, especially in finance hubs) |
CA vs MBBS Salary in India
In terms of initial salary, CA professionals often start higher than MBBS graduates, especially because most doctors begin their careers as interns or junior residents. However, doctors’ earnings grow massively after specialization or private practice.
| Career Stage | MBBS (Doctor) | CA (Chartered Accountant) |
|---|---|---|
| Entry Level | ₹6–8 LPA | ₹8–12 LPA |
| Mid-Level (5–10 years) | ₹12–25 LPA | ₹15–25 LPA |
| Senior/Experienced | ₹25–50 LPA or more (specialist doctor) | ₹25–70 LPA or more (CFO/Partner) |
Which is Tougher — MBBS or CA?
In India, CA is often considered tougher to pass, but MBBS is tougher to complete.
- CA is tough because: it has extremely low pass rates, high conceptual depth, and self-study requirements.
- MBBS is tough because: it’s a long, exhaustive course demanding patience, rote memory, and clinical skills.
Final Verdict: Statistically, it’s harder to become a CA, but overall, MBBS requires more years of continuous effort.
CA vs Doctor — Which is Better?
There’s no universal winner — it depends on your interests and aptitude.
- If you love science, biology, and helping people — MBBS is your path.
- If you prefer numbers, finance, business, and logic — CA is perfect.
Doctors gain more social respect and stable careers; CAs gain faster financial growth and flexible opportunities in corporate or practice settings.
ACCA or MBBS — Which is Tougher?
ACCA (Association of Chartered Certified Accountants) is globally recognized and slightly easier than India’s CA, with higher pass rates. Compared to MBBS, ACCA is shorter but more technical. MBBS is longer and more emotionally demanding. In short — ACCA is tough academically, MBBS is tough mentally.
MBBS vs CA — Pass Rate Comparison
| Exam | Approx. Pass Percentage |
|---|---|
| CA Foundation | 25–30% |
| CA Final | 8–12% |
| MBBS University Exams | 55–65% |
MBBS vs CA — At a Glance
| Criteria | MBBS | CA |
|---|---|---|
| Course Duration | 5.5 Years | 4.5–5 Years |
| Toughness | Long-term effort | Conceptual and exam-based |
| Success Rate | Moderate | Low |
| Average Salary | ₹6–10 LPA | ₹8–15 LPA |
| Global Opportunities | High (Medical PG, USMLE, etc.) | High (ACCA, CPA) |
| Social Status | Very High | High |
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Q1: MBBS vs CA — which is tougher in India?
A: Statistically, CA is tougher to clear, while MBBS is tougher to sustain and complete. Both require years of consistent effort.
Q2: CA vs MBBS Salary — who earns more?
A: At the start, CA earns more, but experienced doctors (specialists) can surpass them in the long term.
Q3: CA vs Doctor — which is better?
A: Depends on your interest — CA suits finance-minded individuals; MBBS suits those passionate about medicine and patient care.
Q4: MBBS vs CA — which is more respected?
A: In India, doctors enjoy higher social respect, but CAs are equally respected in the business and financial community.
Q5: ACCA or MBBS — which is tougher?
A: ACCA is globally recognized and shorter; MBBS is longer and more demanding in practice and patience.
Conclusion
In conclusion, both MBBS and CA are among India’s toughest and most respected professional courses. If you have the patience and empathy for medicine, choose MBBS. If you love finance, problem-solving, and logic, go for CA. Whichever you choose — success will depend more on your passion and persistence than on the course itself.
){kind=link}